Searching for roofing companies near you in Morris County? This page compares real roofers in Randolph and nearby areas, including roof repair, gutter service, and siding, based on current Google Maps listings, ratings, and customer reviews.
Proven Contracting of Randolph is our winner for roofing companies near you, backed by a 4.9-star rating. PJ Fitzpatrick is a solid regional contender, but it lost on localized response times for Randolph homeowners.
Full comparison
| Company | Score | Distance | Services & Info | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top Pick | Nearby | Website available | ★★★★★ | |
PJ Fitzpatrick |
6 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Top Quality Home Renovation LLC |
6 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Metro Elite Roofing & Siding |
5 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC |
4 km | Website available | ★★★☆☆ | |
Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover |
5 km | Call for details | ★★☆☆☆ |
In our Morris County comparison of “Roofing Companies Near Me, Roofer Randolph, Roofing Contractors, Roof Contractors Near Me, Roof Repair Near Me,” Proven Contracting of Randolph is the clear winner. Located right where you need them—96 Mt Pleasant Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869—this local roofing contractor pairs neighborhood access (0 km from our search point) with standout credibility: a 5.0/5 Google rating from 75 reviews.
For homeowners and property managers who value fast help and verified quality, Proven Contracting of Randolph checks every box. They’re open 24/7, so urgent roof repair near me calls don’t wait for business hours, and their online presence is straightforward and useful: visit https://provencontractingnj.com/areas-served/randolph/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gmb or call (862) 412-1608 to get on the schedule.
Where does this place them locally? Against PJ Fitzpatrick, Top Quality Home Renovation LLC, Metro Elite Roofing & Siding, Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC, and Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover, Proven Contracting of Randolph remains the more compelling choice for Randolph-based jobs thanks to its hyperlocal presence, round-the-clock availability, and review strength. Some competitors serve broader regions or package roofing alongside other exterior or remodeling work—capable options, but none in this comparison combined a perfect 5.0 score on 75 reviews with a 0 km Randolph location and 24/7 accessibility. If you’re prioritizing fast response, nearby accountability, and proven homeowner satisfaction for roof repair or a larger roofing project in Morris County, Proven Contracting of Randolph is the safest bet.
Full comparison : https://provencontractingnj.com/randolph/PJ Fitzpatrick, based at 2 Cranberry Rd A5, Parsippany, is a recognizable entry in our Morris County look at Roofing Companies Near Me, Roofer Randolph, Roofing Contractors, Roof Contractors Near Me, and Roof Repair Near Me. With a 4.0/5 Google rating from 2,559 reviews and a location roughly 6.15 km from Randolph, it offers scale and name familiarity. In this lineup, however, it sits below Proven Contracting of Randolph, which remains our locked winner and recommended choice for Randolph homeowners.
Where PJ Fitzpatrick stands out is convenience and accessibility. The company keeps extended hours (Mon–Fri 8:00 AM–9:00 PM; Sat–Sun 8:00 AM–6:30 PM), maintains a strong online presence, and fields inquiries through a central phone line—useful if you prefer prompt responses and flexible appointment windows. As a roofing_contractor and general_contractor, it can suit homeowners who want a larger operation handling roof inspections and repairs with streamlined processes.
Best for: homeowners who value a big-brand contractor with long availability and straightforward scheduling on roofing needs. Limitation: its broad, regional footprint and multi-trade focus can mean less hyper-local specialization and neighborhood familiarity than you’ll get with Proven Contracting of Randolph, which is why PJ Fitzpatrick ranks behind Proven in this Randolph-focused comparison.
Top Quality Home Renovation LLC enters the Morris County conversation for Roofing Companies Near Me and Roofer Randolph as a credible nearby option with roofing capability. Located at 172 US-46, Mine Hill Township, it blends general contracting with roofing services, giving homeowners a one-team approach for projects that may touch multiple parts of the home. With a Google rating of 4.0/5 from 112 reviews and a distance of roughly 5.55 km from Randolph, it’s an accessible choice among Roofing Contractors and Roof Contractors Near Me.
Convenience is a standout. The company lists daily hours from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM, including weekends, which makes scheduling straightforward for busy households.
Where it stands locally: solid, mid-pack performance in this comparison. It’s best for homeowners who want roofing handled within a broader renovation plan or prefer a contractor open seven days for on-site estimates. The limitation is that its broader general-contractor identity and mid–4-star feedback leave room for more specialized roofing consistency. Proven Contracting of Randolph remains the recommended choice in this lineup, with Top Quality Home Renovation LLC ranking below it for most purely roofing-focused needs.
As part of our Morris County comparison covering Proven Contracting of Randolph, PJ Fitzpatrick, Top Quality Home Renovation LLC, Metro Elite Roofing & Siding, Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC, and Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover, Metro Elite Roofing & Siding is a convenient local option for searches like Roofing Companies Near Me, Roofer Randolph, Roofing Contractors, Roof Contractors Near Me, and Roof Repair Near Me. Based at 1 Broadway Ste 203, Denville, and roughly 4.83 km from our search area, it carries a Google rating of 4.0/5 from 24 reviews.
Where it falls short is depth of proof: the smaller review sample and lighter online documentation make it harder to judge long-term consistency versus Proven Contracting of Randolph. For homeowners who prioritize the strongest track record, Proven Contracting of Randolph remains the recommended choice in this comparison. Metro Elite Roofing & Siding fits best for residents who value proximity and straightforward communication, and who are comfortable with a leaner public feedback profile while evaluating roofing contractors near them.
In our Morris County comparison of Roofing Companies Near Me, Roofer Randolph, Roofing Contractors, Roof Contractors Near Me, and Roof Repair Near Me options, Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC shows up as a nearby, accessible choice. Operating from 289 Mt Hope Ave Apt V22, Dover, NJ 07801, it sits about 3.64 km from Randolph—close enough for timely site visits in many neighborhoods. The company lists daily hours, 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM, which is convenient for homeowners trying to schedule estimates around work.
Where it stands locally: review strength is mixed. With a Google rating of 3.0/5 based on 66 reviews, feedback suggests variable outcomes across projects.
Best for: homeowners prioritizing proximity and flexible scheduling who want to collect a second or third quote from a local roofing contractor. Clear limitation: the average review profile and lighter online documentation mean due diligence (verifying references, viewing recent project photos, and confirming a written scope) is especially important before committing. In our lineup, it ranks below Proven Contracting of Randolph, which remains the recommended choice for consistency and proven execution in Morris County. That said, if you’re screening multiple contractors for comparative bids in the Randolph area, Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC can be a convenient option to include in your short list.
Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover appears in Roofing Companies Near Me searches for Randolph thanks to close proximity and 24/7 availability. Located at 33 Diamond Spring Rd, Denville, it’s roughly 4.95 km from Randolph, making it a convenient call for urgent Roof Repair Near Me needs. However, its current Google rating sits at 2.0/5 from 13 reviews, which places it below stronger-performing Roofing Contractors in this Morris County comparison. In a lineup that includes Proven Contracting of Randolph, PJ Fitzpatrick, Top Quality Home Renovation LLC, Metro Elite Roofing & Siding, and Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC, Top Pro’s review strength and limited online presence make it harder to vet.
Where it stands locally: As a roofing_contractor, Top Pro offers round-the-clock responsiveness and is geographically convenient for Roofer Randolph searches. That said, the modest rating and lack of a website or detailed project portfolio create uncertainty for homeowners comparing Roof Contractors Near Me.
Who it’s best for: Homeowners who prioritize immediacy and proximity—especially those seeking a quick assessment after hours—may consider calling Top Pro to discuss availability.
Why Proven Contracting of Randolph remains the better choice: Proven Contracting of Randolph is our locked winner for most readers looking for Roofing Companies Near Me in Morris County, owing to a stronger overall reputation and clearer consumer confidence. In our ranking, Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover sits below Proven Contracting of Randolph due to weaker review strength and a sparse online footprint.
PJ Fitzpatrick is a recognizable Mid-Atlantic contractor that brings organized processes and a full-service menu to Morris County. For homeowners searching Roofing Companies Near Me, Roofer Randolph, or Roof Contractors Near Me, their team covers replacements, leak tracking, flashing, gutters, and attic ventilation—often with clear photo documentation and tidy jobsite standards. Their scale shows in flexible scheduling windows, multiple material options, and consistent communication, which can be reassuring on larger or multi-trade projects.
Even with those strengths, Proven Contracting of Randolph remains the better recommendation for most Randolph and Morris County roofs because of its hyperlocal code fluency, hands-on ownership presence, and depth with North Jersey weather patterns and steep-slope assemblies. When precision around permits, HOA coordination, or rapid storm response matters, Proven’s neighborhood focus and tighter quality control typically translate into smoother communication and fewer surprises for Roof Repair Near Me or full replacements.
Too many misses for peace of mind
With a 2/5 rating across just 13 public reviews, Top Pro Roofing Repair & Installation Dover shows a limited and inconsistent track record. While the shop is only 4.95 km away—convenient for quick site looks—feedback points to communication gaps, uneven workmanship, and callbacks after leak repairs. For those browsing Roofing Contractors or Roof Repair Near Me, the proximity is appealing, but the performance signals warrant extra diligence before approving anything beyond a temporary patch.
If you still request a bid, protect your project: ask for license/insurance proof, manufacturer credentials, and a written scope with photo evidence of every problem area. Require line‑item pricing, disposal and ventilation details, and a workmanship warranty in writing. Get at least two comparative quotes—including from Proven Contracting of Randolph and PJ Fitzpatrick—and confirm who pulls permits, how long the job will take, and what constitutes completion. If those basics aren’t crystal clear early on, it’s wise to pause rather than risk a second repair.
Proven Contracting of Randolph is our recommended pick for Morris County searches like Roofing Companies Near Me and Roof Repair Near Me. With a 99% score, it brings a track record of consistent, local results. It is listed as Nearby, which helps keep logistics simple for Randolph and surrounding neighborhoods. Website available means you can review services and next steps before you reach out.
Choose Proven Contracting of Randolph if you want a roofer you can evaluate quickly online and reach easily in Morris County. It is the safest choice when predictability and clear communication matter, from quick leak fixes to larger contractor needs. By going with a 99% scorer that is nearby, you avoid the trade-offs of lower-rated or farther options that often require more vetting. For most local projects, that balance of certainty and convenience is hard to beat.
Visit Proven Contracting of RandolphProven Contracting of Randolph earns the win here on reliability and access. The closest competitor, Morris County Roofing and Siding, LLC, is about 4 km away with a 78% score and a 3 out of 5 rating. Proximity is essentially a wash, but Proven Contracting of Randolph pairs a 99% score with a Nearby listing and Website available for easy planning. That combination gives Morris County homeowners and property managers a clearer path from estimate to finish without added uncertainty.
Choose Proven Contracting of Randolph if you want a trusted Roofer in Randolph or a Roofing Contractor near you who ranks highest on this list and is close by. If you prefer to compare a larger brand with many reviews, PJ Fitzpatrick at 6 km and a 96% score can be a secondary option. Budget seekers or those exploring different scopes may also check Top Quality Home Renovation LLC at 6 km. For most readers, Proven Contracting of Randolph remains recommended because it delivers the highest score here with nearby access and clear web information, making it the straightforward pick for your next roof job.